Stubble Burning after Fall Fertilization – Am I Ok?

Bobby Golden, Agronomist, Delta REC, Mississippi State University
By Bobby Golden, Agronomist, Delta REC, Mississippi State University September 13, 2013 08:44

Stubble Burning after Fall Fertilization – Am I Ok?

Corn Stubble BurningA common question that I have received from numerous consultants over the last several days is as follows.  Hey don’t hammer me, but what happens if we mistakenly burned our corn stubble after we spread fall mixed good fertilizer and lime?  At the speed in which we harvest and prepare for the next planting season in the Delta it’s an easy thing to happen with labor that is stretched out.  Over the last two weeks I have received calls about this subject ranging from both North and South Delta and all points in between.

The first question asked is how bad it is going to hurt me?  I think most feel like, I just spent around 80 to $100/acre and threw a match on it something’s got to happen to the nutrients right?  Well not necessarily.  Temperatures reached from most residue burning practices will not affect the physical properties of Lime, Potash, and/or Triple Super Phosphate.  The temperatures are simply not hot enough to cause loss, and unlike nitrogen and sulfur, these three fertilizer materials are not volatile.

If it makes you feel better. Think about the way fertilizer guarantees are expressed on a bag of fertilizer. For P and K we talk about P2O5 and K2O, which are the elements in the oxide form. Why do we do this?  Before new technological laboratory advancements to guarantee fertilizer grade, the old method was to weigh the fertilizer after combustion.  This method allowed the impurities in the fertilizer to burn off and we are left with P2O5 and K2O oxide ash.  By this logic,  even if the corn stubble fire gets hot enough to influence the physical properties of Potash and TSP, you still are Ok.

The greatest concern from residue burning after fertilization would be nutrient movement within and out of the field via wind erosion.  Most everyone has heard me say at one time or another that when we burn stubble a portion of our nutrients contained in the stubble float off in the ash that lands on the pickup truck window. This would hold true too for any fertilizer material that may get picked up in the vortex we usually see coming off of burned corn fields.  Also, depending on the fineness of lime spread, wind erosion after burning could move lime away from target areas simply because there is little to no corn stubble left to provide a wind break.

So in short is burning after fertilization a practice I would suggest?  Common sense and the feel good aspect says NO and I tend to agree.  However, if you find yourself in the situation where fertilizer and lime have been spread and the field is then burned, you can ease up a little knowing that you are not losing the nutrients you just spent money on spreading.

Remember you are going to lose a portion of the nutrients that were contained in the stubble and valuable organic matter, and that decision was made when we elect to burn the field. For more on this aspect go to: http://www.mississippi-crops.com/2013/09/03/burning-stalks-what-does-it-really-cost/

Print Friendly

Bobby Golden, Agronomist, Delta REC, Mississippi State University
By Bobby Golden, Agronomist, Delta REC, Mississippi State University September 13, 2013 08:44
Write a comment

No Comments

No Comments Yet!

Let me tell You a sad story ! There are no comments yet, but You can be first one to comment this article.

Write a comment
View comments

Write a comment

Your e-mail address will not be published.
Required fields are marked*

Subscribe to receive updates

  • Soybean Harvest Aids

    Several calls have come in over the last week regarding soybean harvest aid options for various scenarios. In some cases, fields have been observed with varying degrees of maturity. In ...
  • Sugarcane Aphid Control with Falling Temperatures

    In 2014 we saw two incidents of less than satisfactory control with Transform on sugarcane aphids in grain sorghum across a broad geography. At the time we were mixing a ...
  • Pheromone Trap Counts, August 28. 2015

    Bollworm trap catches remained similar to last week, which is somewhat lower than average for this time of year. Tobacco budworm trap catches were somewhat higher this week. As most ...
  • Pheromone Trap Counts, August 21, 2015

    Bollworm moth trap catches were slightly higher in most counties this week but are generally lower than average counts for this time of year. Tobacco budworm moths continued to be ...
  • Defoliating Caterpillars in Peanuts

    We have had numerous calls over the last 2 weeks about caterpillars in peanut from all around the state. In every case, the calls have involved a complex of multiple species including bollworm/tobacco budworm, cutworms, armyworms, saltmarsh caterpillar, loopers, and rednecked peanut worm. ...
  • 3rd Annual Mississippi Sweetpotato Field Day Program- August 27th

    Mississippi State University will host its 3rd Annual Sweetpotato Field Day Thursday August 27 at the Pontotoc Ridge-Flatwoods Branch Experiment Station (8320 Hwy 15 S., Pontotoc, MS 38863).  Registration is ...

More Info By