Mississippi Crop Situation

Researching Row Rice

Bobby Golden, Agronomist, Delta REC, Mississippi State University
By Bobby Golden, Agronomist, Delta REC, Mississippi State University and Dan Roach, Ext. Associate January 18, 2019 10:28

Researching Row Rice

Related Articles

Latest Tweets

Producing rice in a “rowed-up” manner as other row crops such as corn, soybean, and cotton was a foreign concept just a couple of years ago. Row rice or furrow irrigated rice was initially investigated by MSU  Researchers as an alternative to conventional flooded rice production in the 80’s.  Some of you may recall Dr. Joe Street and Dr. Ted Miller worked with Clarksdale’s Leon Bramlett in exploring the agronomic’s of furrow irrigated rice. Mr. Bramlett wanted an alternate crop to raise on his traditional cotton farm.  The idea of furrow irrigated rice was began in Mississippi. This was long before the introduction of the “new” rice herbicides Facet, Command, Newpath, and Clearpath, and issues with weed control ultimately led to the abandonment of the concept. Today, there is tremendous interest in growing furrow irrigated rice vs. growing rice in a typical flooded environment. In 2016, the MSU Irrigation team, due to Producer demand,  started investigating furrow irrigated rice.  Graduate student, Lee Atwill has completed two years of small plot research at the Delta Research and Extension center here in Stoneville.  A summary of his research is presented below.

Atwill investigated both an conventional and the Clearfield herbicide system utilizing three rice cultivars, CL151, Rex, and XL745 (RiceTec). Six different rice irrigation treatments were also included: a continuous flood, an optimized AWD treatment allowing the flood to recede to 4″ below the soil surface while maintaining flood water on the bottom side of the plots, 4” below the soil surface, 8” below the soil surface, 12” below the soil surface, and 16” below the soil surface. Water levels in each paddy were monitored utilizing a Pani pipe and irrigation events were triggered at each respective threshold.   While individual herbicide treatments preformed well in Atwill’s trial, additional scouting may be required for broadleafs weed with implementing row rice.

Nitrogen management was also investigated using the different rice cultivars and  irrigation treatments. The results suggest that when nitrogen is applied utilizing a three way spilt of 50/25/25,  highest yields were achieved.  The other treatments; 100% pre flood, two thirds/one third split, and 25%/25%/25%/25% all resulted in the similar yield.  All fertilizer (NBPT treated) applications were applied to wet soils with the exception of the initial pre flood treatments.

Rice yields among irrigation treatments resulted in the continuous flood and optimized AWD treatments producing similar results.  All other irrigation plots were statistically similar resulting in a 20 bushel yield decrease compared to continuous flood and optimized AWD.  It should be noted that the optimized AWD allowed the water on the top side of the plots to receded to 4″ below the soil surface while maintaining flood water on the bottom side of the plots.  The other row rice irrigation treatments differ in that the entire plot was allowed to dry equally from top to bottom.  These small plot trial  “worst case” scenarios helps explain the yield variation we have seen in the “on farm” trial work.

Data from “on farm” trials helps MSU Researchers understand some of the yield perimeters associated with furrow irrigated rice.  If you ask experienced furrow irrigated rice producers one thing is clear, they recognize only a small, if any, yield reduction.  MSU Researchers, recognizing the significant yield reduction observed in small plot data compared to producer experience, began looking deeper into the on farm data for answers.

The two year furrow irrigated rice small plot data suggest that a continuous flood irrigation and an optimized AWD (allowing the flood to recede to 4″ below the soil surface while maintaining flood water on the bottom side of the plots) irrigation yield substantially better than allowing the soil to become dry.  When you think about what actually happens on the farm, each field of furrow irrigated rice is actually three sub fields.  As demonstrated  by the example, the top one third is the driest, the middle is similar to the optimized AWD treatments (soupy wet but never dry), and the bottom one third resembles a continuous irrigated field. This yield map is from a furrow irrigated field that was divided by a levee in the center of the field, essentially two individual fields. Water was held by the levee, as well as the flash board riser.

When you break down the yield in each sub section, the top of the field, the driest, yields were reduced by 12%.  The center part of the field, the optimized AWD section (part that remains soupy) yields were reduced by 7%.  The section on the bottom side of the field with a continuous flood yielded the highest.

The take home from this analysis is: furrow irrigation fields where producers keep the field moist and are holding an continuous flood on the bottom one third of the field can expect a yield reduction in the 8-10 bushel range.  Producers where the grade of the field will not allow the holding an continuous flood on the bottom side of the field can expect substantial yield losses in the 20 bushel range.

Here is the adjacent conventional levee yield map compared to the row rice field. In this comparison, the whole field average of the row rice field was equal to the conventional levee field.  The adjacent  conventional levee field was on .20 grade with levees every 100′, contributing to a lower field average.  Fields with grades great than .20 can be a good fit for row rice.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Bobby Golden, Agronomist, Delta REC, Mississippi State University
By Bobby Golden, Agronomist, Delta REC, Mississippi State University and Dan Roach, Ext. Associate January 18, 2019 10:28
Write a comment

No Comments

No Comments Yet!

Let me tell You a sad story ! There are no comments yet, but You can be first one to comment this article.

Write a comment
View comments

Write a comment

<

Subscribe to receive updates

More Info By